Trusted Dental Care, Creating Lasting Smiles
Comfort matters in dental care, and so does trust. At The Extra Smile, Dr. Tim Hoftiezer and our team provide gentle, comprehensive dentistry focused on long-term oral health and a calm, unhurried experience. Located in Carmel, IN, we welcome new patients from Carmel, Westfield, Noblesville, Zionsville, and Fishers, and we have built a practice where every visit feels manageable from the moment you walk in.
Whether you are coming in for a routine cleaning, exploring cosmetic options, or replacing a missing tooth, our team is here to guide you through each step with clear explanations and patient-centered care.
Dental Implants
Strong, Natural-Looking Tooth Replacement
- Bring back your natural smile and confidence with comfortable, long-lasting tooth replacement.
Dental Cleaning
Gentle, Personalized Care
- From routine appointments to deep cleanings, our team offers comfortable, thorough care that leaves you feeling confident.
Invisalign®
A Clear Path to a More Confident Smile
- Enjoy a straighter smile with clear aligners that are easy to wear and fit right into your everyday life.
Sedation Dentistry
& Nitrous Oxide
Relaxed, Stress-Free Visits
- Feel at ease during your visit with gentle, stress-free options that help you relax in the chair.
Straighten Your Smile Comfortably and Discreetly
We’re proud to offer Invisalign® as a clear, comfortable alternative to traditional braces. These custom aligners are nearly invisible and gently shift your teeth into place—perfect for adults and teens looking to improve spacing, crowding, or alignment without the brackets and wires.
Dr. Hoftiezer’s advanced training and personalized approach ensure your treatment is smooth and supported every step of the way.
It’s never too late to love your smile—and with Invisalign®, the journey is easier than you think.
Take the Stress Out of Your Visit with Gentle Sedation Options
We know that visiting a dentist office in Carmel can feel overwhelming for some patients, and that’s okay. That’s why we offer safe, personalized sedation options, including nitrous oxide, to help you feel calm and comfortable from start to finish.
Whether you’re here for a routine cleaning or a more involved procedure, Dr. Hoftiezer and our caring team are here to make your experience as smooth and stress-free as possible. Your comfort matters, and we’re here to help you feel at ease every step of the way.
The Healthy
Smiles Plan
Affordable, Worry-Free Dental
Care for You and Your Family
Our Healthy Smiles Plan is a simple, affordable dental membership designed for individuals and families—no insurance needed. With no waiting periods, no deductibles, and no yearly maximums, you can start using your benefits right away. You’ll enjoy routine cleanings, exams, and X-rays, along with exclusive savings on additional treatments.
There are no claim forms, no exclusions for pre-existing conditions, and no hidden fees—just straightforward, stress-free care to keep your smile healthy year-round.
Friendly Faces, Exceptional Care
Our team is more than just skilled professionals—we’re caring people who love what we do! From the front desk to the treatment room, every member of our team is here to make you feel comfortable, heard, and cared for.
We’re proud to create a warm, welcoming environment where patients of all ages feel at ease—and where the friendly faces behind your care make every visit feel personal.
Why Choose The Extra Smile in Carmel, IN
Comfort and trust should come standard in dental care. Here is what sets our practice apart:
-
Comfort-first environment with sedation dentistry options, including nitrous oxide, for anxious patients
-
Comprehensive care under one roof, from routine cleanings and teeth whitening to dental implants and Invisalign
-
Healthy Smiles membership plan for patients without insurance who want predictable preventive care and savings
-
Recognized expertise, Dr. Hoftiezer is a Top Dentist honored by Indianapolis Monthly for 15 years in a row
-
Transparent, patient-focused communication so you always feel informed, calm, and in control of your care
-
Convenient Carmel location with easy parking and accessible entryways
Meet Dr. Tim Hoftiezer, Your Carmel Dentist
Choosing a dentist means choosing someone you can trust with your health. Dr. Tim Hoftiezer is the founder and lead dentist at The Extra Smile. He earned his D.D.S. with honors from the Indiana University School of Dentistry and holds advanced training in preventive care, Invisalign, cosmetic dentistry, and dental implants, including certifications in both implant placement and restoration.
Dr. Hoftiezer has been recognized by Indianapolis Monthly as a ‘Top Dentist’ for 15 consecutive years, including 2026. Patients value his calm, attentive approach, his careful listening, and his commitment to dentistry that supports lifelong oral health.
Learn more about our practice and team and see why patients across Carmel, Fishers, Westfield, Noblesville, and Zionsville continue to trust The Extra Smile
Frequently Asked Questions
Do you accept new patients from Westfield, Fishers, or Noblesville?
Yes. While we are located in Carmel, IN, we warmly welcome new patients from Westfield, Noblesville, Zionsville, Fishers, and surrounding communities. Our location is easy to reach, with convenient parking right next to the office. Contact us to schedule your first visit.
What options are available if I do not have dental insurance?
Our Healthy Smiles membership plan is designed specifically for patients without insurance. It includes two annual cleanings, all exams and necessary X-rays, fluoride treatments, oral cancer screening, and 20% off all additional dental treatment, with no waiting periods or deductibles.
Does The Extra Smile offer options for patients who are nervous about dental visits?
Absolutely. Supporting anxious patients is a core part of how we care. We offer sedation dentistry in Carmel, including nitrous oxide, to help you feel relaxed and comfortable throughout your visit. Dr. Hoftiezer and our team take time to explain every step so there are no surprises.
Testimonials
Hear What Our Patients Are Saying
Schedule Your Appointment at The Extra Smile
Care should feel manageable, and your next step should feel simple. Whether you need a routine cleaning, want to explore cosmetic options like dental veneers or Invisalign, or are ready to discuss dental implants or dentures, we are here to help.
Request an appointment today and experience a dentist office in Carmel, IN built around comfort, trust, and your long-term health.